Off-line fishing: Recreational fisherman Graham Longhurst at the Thornton boat ramp, with his trusty boat, For Reel, on which every scratch and dent denotes a fishing adventure in the waters around Whakatāne. Photo Diane McCarthy E6256(13)
Diane McCarthy
An 87-year-old recreational fisherman, unaware of new charges for Whakatāne boat ramps, is among recipients of 46 breach notices issued since November 1.
Graham Longhurst, a retired schoolteacher and author of Ramblings of a Hooker, a self-published collection of stories about his fishing adventures, said the breach notice and associated fine came “out of the blue”.
Longhurst said he would have been glad to pay the “trivial” $20 fee for a resident permit, if only he had known about it.
“I would happily pay double,” he said.
However, when he launched his trusty 4.2-metre fishing boat, For Reel, from the boat ramp at Thornton, pre-dawn on November 4, he was not aware ramp fees were in place.
Whakatāne District Council introduced the boat ramp fees of $20 a day, and one-off payments of $20 for a boat ramp permit for Eastern Bay residents, in early October.
Following a one-month grace period during which messaging was put out across various media platforms, issuing of breach notices started this month.
“As a homeowner and ratepayer in this beautiful town, I happily pay my council rates. Sadly, I do not subscribe to a newspaper and do not regularly listen to local news,” Longhurst said.
He did not see the signs stating fees or a permit were required before using the boat ramp.
“The early bird catches the worm. I go out when it’s still dark. There were no visible streetlights, and the boat ramp lights weren’t working. I’m not going to walk around with a torch looking for a sign that I didn’t know existed,” he said.
Having never owned a cellphone, he would not have been able to scan the QR Code to purchase a permit if he had seen it.
As it turned out, conditions were not ideal for him to cross the bar and he put his boat back on its trailer after 10 minutes and launched from Whakatāne boat ramp instead.
Within eight days, he received a notice through the mail with a $75 fine for breaching Ōkōrero (Thornton) boat ramp conditions by not having a permit.
He did not receive a breach notice for using the Whakatāne ramp less than an hour later, which the council put down to an issue with power cuts to the licence plate recognition cameras monitoring the boat ramp, caused by floodwall works that had since been resolved.
Longhurst went to the council to ask about the notice but was told he could not dispute the fine or purchase a permit from them. It could only be done online, through a web portal of Stellar from Stellar, the Auckland-based company managing the boat ramp fees and enforcement on behalf of the council.
“I don’t know how to go online, and the council wouldn’t take my money,” he said.
“Eventually a young, very patient guy came out and listened to my story and guided me through the whole procedure.”
He now has a permit but has not resolved the fine. He feels entitled to dispute it due to his inability to see the sign in the dark, but to do so, he is faced with another technological hurdle.
The breach notice directs recipients to an online portal for disputes and offers no phone number but has a $20 penalty if not paid by November 27.
A phone number on Stellar’s website is answered by a recorded message stating phone operators were not able to resolve disputes and recommends emailing [email protected].
“I believe so strongly that the entire boat ramp saga is a shambles, paralleling the Whakatāne marina one of a few years ago, that I am happy to follow due process.
“I suppose that I will be informed when to appear in court,” Longhurst said.
He also spoke to someone launching his boat at the Whakatāne Boat Ramp this week who also had no idea the council had begun charging ramp fees.
“There must be lots of oldies who don’t bother with cellphones or take them when they go out. I know at least one other who only recently sold his boat.”
Council ports manager Mark Read said messaging continued across multiple platforms encouraging people to get their permit before heading out on the water.
“While local resident permits are managed through the online vPermit system, people who need assistance can contact the council and staff can help them through the process,” he said.
The council’s customer services team has so far assisted three of the 682 people who have registered for permits.
“The council recognises that not everyone is comfortable using online services and we don’t want that to be a barrier to obtaining a permit.”
The council had no record of any lighting outages at the Ōkōrero/Thornton ramp, but since Longhurst’s complaint, had raised a job with its street light provider.
